
More than 60 residents signed up to speak at the Nov. 17, 2026, Sarasota County Commission meeting. Most were there to support an appeal of a recent order in a Live Local lawsuit that paved the way for 864 apartments on land next to the celery fields. | Photo by Christian Casale, Suncoast Searchlight
Sarasota County gives up Live Local lawsuit, clears way for Celery Fields development
Sarasota County Commissioners waved the white flag Tuesday after months of litigation with developers over the Live Local Act, giving up their fight and paving the way for thousands of apartments to be built in agricultural neighborhoods.
Commissioners voted 3-2 not to appeal a Nov. 4 order from Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll siding with developers who sued the county earlier this year after the county blocked their applications in areas where current zoning laws allow for as few as one home per 10 acres.
Tuesday’s decision now clears the way for more than 7,600 proposed units across 18 projects seeking to use the controversial Live Local Act, a state law that allows developers to bypass traditional public hearings and local government scrutiny if a portion of the projects are set aside for affordable housing.
Dozens of residents opposed to projects packed the commission chambers on Tuesday to plead for the county to continue fighting. They warned about destruction to the environment and increased traffic congestion — and they attacked national builder D.R. Horton as a “bully” for repeated attempts to develop near the Celery Fields bird sanctuary.
The crowds became so raucous at times that Commission Chairman Ron Cutsinger stopped the meeting for a 10-minute recess to restore order.
Tuesday’s decision marked a reversal for Commissioner Tom Knight, who had been among the county’s most vocal advocates for fighting Live Local developments in court. Knight joined Commissioners Cutsinger and Jim DeNiro in voting to abandon the appeal.
The vote was also DeNiro’s first since winning his November election on pledges to “Stop Overdevelopment” — a message stamped on his roadside campaign signs.

Sarasota County Commissioner Jim DeNiro was sworn into office on Tuesday. His first meeting was a loaded affair as he voted with Commissioner Tom Knight and Ron Cutsinger to end the county’s legal resistance to the Live Local Act. | Photo by Christian Casale, Suncoast Searchlight
The former Sarasota Police Department officer ran as a slow-growth Republican but voted to end the county’s legal fight without speaking during commissioner discussions.
After their vote to end the lawsuit, commissioners authorized the county attorney to try to purchase the property near Celery Fields that D.R. Horton has eyed for Live Local.
“The people (who) were here earlier today, God bless them,” Knight said as he tried to justify reversing course. “We were looking out for them when we did this. We’re trying to protect our citizens from Tallahassee.”
Smith property pivotal in Live Local fight
This is at least the third time that residents have shown up in force over the last two years to demand the county protect a 51-acre property near Celery Fields, a major stormwater hub that helps control flooding.
D.R. Horton has been pushing to build on the land since at least 2023, but each time a plan reached the elected leaders, they shot it down, often after hours of public outrage. When plans for 85 single-family homes were rejected, the Texas-based company turned to Live Local with blueprints calling for 864 apartments in buildings that would stand 65 feet.
When the county again denied that project — arguing that the underlying zoning on the property excluded it from the state’s affordable housing program — the company filed suit and joined multiple other real estate interests challenging the county on its interpretation.
Even though Carroll has only ruled in the D.R. Horton case, his rationale that Sarasota County’s argument was meritless will eventually be applied to the other cases. Carroll is also the judge on the other Live Local cases.
The judge’s decision to allow the D.R. Horton project to be processed under Live Local noted it would still need to meet all other areas of Sarasota County’s land development code.
The commissioners’ vote also followed a legal brief Attorney General James Uthmeier filed in support of the developer’s position in one of the Live Local cases last week, something Cutsinger and Knight both referenced as to seeing the “writing on the wall” about an eventual appeal.
“The county’s actions undermine the Legislature’s express preemption of local land development regulation, disrupt the uniform statewide application of Florida housing law and policy, and invite other local governments to nullify duly enacted statutes through pretextual administrative maneuvering,” Uthmeier wrote in the legal brief.
Charlie Bailey, an attorney who represents D.R. Horton, said on Tuesday that if commissioners would agree to the 126-home development they previously rejected, the builder would abandon its application to build apartments under Live Local.

On the popular bird tracking app eBird, Celery Fields is ranked as the third most popular birding hotspot in Florida. Photo provided by Sarasota County.
Bailey’s comment drew boos from the crowd. He told the commissioners that his client isn’t in the land speculation business and that he didn’t think they had “really given serious consideration” to selling the property.
Commissioner Teresa Mast, whose district covers the Celery Fields, said she had a personal plea for the Smith family for the county to make an offer on buying their property. She said that after the 2024 storms flooded parts of the county, it was vital to preserve the land.
“I don’t like losing,” Mast said. “I know that we fought really hard. I know we will continue to fight really hard. But genuinely, I want to have a real conversation about this.”
Crowd overwhelms county commission chamber to denounce development
Andromeda Rhea first spoke out against the proposed Celery Fields development in February 2025, when she was 9-years-old.
Now 11 and in 6th grade, she spoke about the project again on Tuesday, fearing construction on the site would impact the nearby wildlife habitat.
“Soot and ash can cover up the plants, and they can wither and die because the sun will be blocked,” Rhea said during public comment. “And pollution is bad for our air. It will get very hard to breathe if we don’t have good air.”
Rhea was joined by dozens of public commenters who blasted the development, and who urged Sarasota County to appeal the judge’s Live Local ruling.
Some also raised concerns that the area – south of Fruitville Road on the east side of Interstate 75 – already exceeds traffic capacity for new developments. Other apartment buildings and county facilities have sprouted up there in recent years, including Sarasota County’s new $100 million administration building, the interior of which is dotted with photographs of migratory birds.
Speaker after speaker expressed an existential dread about the state of “wild Florida” in the face of development booms.

Gator guy: Justin Fletcher and his “emotional support alligator” speak out against the proposed development near the Celery Fields at a Sarasota County Commission meeting. | Photo by Christian Casale, Suncoast Searchlight
The proposed 65-foot buildings in the 864-apartment project could lead to increased noise, increased light and disrupt the fragile birding habitat that doubles as the county’s stormwater facility, said Sara Reisinger, president of the Sarasota Audubon Society.
The development would also create a bird strike hazard that could drive birds away from what has become a tourism draw for the county.
Reisinger said even the single-story Audubon nature center located at Celery Fields has had birds smack into its glass windows.
“Bird strikes are a real issue,” she said while noting that’s one of the leading causes of deaths for birds, “and a huge concern especially on a building with large glass windows.”
During public comment, Justin Fletcher approached the podium with a 3-foot-long stuffed animal, his “emotional support alligator.” He read off a century of Sarasota’s history from a book and old newspapers: from the drainage of the Palmer Farms, the formation of the Celery Fields and the long history of real estate booms and busts.
“Throughout this book, it continuously repeats itself about the boom and bust cycles of reckless land speculations,” Fletcher said. “They’ve taken away everything from us at this point. What’s next?”
Derek Gilliam is a watchdog/investigative reporter for Suncoast Searchlight and previously covered real estate, development and local business for the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. Email Derek at derek@suncoastsearchlight.org.
Christian Casale is a reporter for Suncoast Searchlight who covers local government and politics, and previously covered local government for the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. Email Christian at christian@suncoastsearchlight.org.





