Business owners in the rapidly-growing Rosemary District have for years pressed the Sarasota City Commission for more public parking in the neighborhood. | Photo by Christian Casale, Suncoast Searchlight

Sarasota kills $8 million public parking plan for Rosemary District

Published On: November 16, 2026 6:39 pmLast Updated: November 16, 2026 6:42 pm

The Sarasota City Commission rejected a proposal Monday to spend at least $8 million on more public parking in the Rosemary District, despite growing concerns over a lack of spaces in the up-and-coming neighborhood.

The plan called for adding 160 spots in a new parking garage as part of the McCown Towers expansion, on the corner of Cocoanut Avenue and Boulevard of the Arts. The housing project will still move forward, adding 96 affordable units for elderly people who qualify for federal housing assistance, along with 183 parking spaces reserved for new and existing residents.

But additional public parking will no longer be included.

The rejection is a blow to Rosemary District business owners, who say lack of public parking is hurting their establishments and that parking availability has failed to keep pace with the neighborhood’s growth.

It also leaves the Sarasota Housing Authority on the hook for roughly $500,000 in costs associated with redesigning the project and pursuing a parking agreement that would have benefited the city — not low-income residents — and that ultimately fell apart. William Russell, CEO of the Housing Authority, said public parking was not part of the development’s initial plan, but came after conversations between his board and city officials.

Now through Dec. 31, NewsMatch will triple your gift: $50 becomes $150, $500 becomes $1,500 and $1,000 becomes $3,000. Give now, and triple my impact. Now through Dec. 31, NewsMatch will triple your gift $50 becomes $150 • $500 becomes $1,500 • $1,000 becomes $3,000 Give now, and triple my impact

“Because of the outcome, it comes out to be a waste of time and money,” Russell told Suncoast Searchlight in the City Hall lobby after the commission’s vote.

The decision also follows months of turmoil in the city’s parking department, which has relied on loans from the general fund to cover revenue shortfalls and reversed course on a plan to raise parking fees after widespread public outcry. The controversy ultimately led the city to transfer parking enforcement to the Sarasota Police Department.

Mayor Kathy Kelley Ohlrich and Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch were joined by new Commissioner Flo Entler in rejecting the proposal.

Ohlrich cited concerns over a provision that the city would lease the parking spots, rather than own them. Ahearn-Koch pointed to other parking projects approved with the same assumption, that they would be self-sustaining, but did not pan out. Entler said she had heard concerns from local residents about the garage while on the campaign trail.

The commissioners also cited Amendment 3, the constitutional provision passed earlier this month that will slash both property taxes and the budgets of local governments across Florida.

The $8 million earmarked by the city for the garage could have climbed to $13.8 million with non-tax-exempt financing costs at a 6% interest rate. Commissioners also worried that Amendment 3 could make it harder for the city to take on additional debt. 

“There are so many unknowns and so many uncertainties,” Entler said. “And with Amendment 3, I just don’t know how to responsibly say yes to this.” 

Melissa Laughlin, president of the Rosemary District Association, said in public comment that she spoke on behalf of her board, local businesses and many residents as she urged the commission to approve what she called a concrete solution to a yearslong parking deficiency.

She was joined by the owners of local restaurants, like Toasted Mango and Arts & Central, who also cited concerns about a lack of parking for their customers.

“We can’t survive as a neighborhood without this,” Laughlin said. “As you’re making fiscally responsible trade-offs and decisions, this is something that’s bringing money into the neighborhood.”

A city spokesperson referred inquiries from Suncoast Searchlight about the Rosemary District’s parking deficiencies to the Sarasota Police Department, which took over parking enforcement in October.

Lt. Dwayne Shellhammer, the SPD’s parking services lieutenant, said the city is working with consultants to evaluate parking conditions in the neighborhood and explore solutions. He mentioned that the city is exploring the feasibility of a parking garage, but no decisions have been finalized.

“Parking in the Rosemary District is a complex issue, as there are competing demands for a limited number of spaces among residents, businesses, employees, customers and schools,” Shellhammer said.

An rendering of the planned expansion of McCown Towers. | Image courtesy of the Sarasota Housing Authority.

Commissioners cite financial insecurity, parking woes for denial of project

Once the center of Sarasota’s historic Black community, the Rosemary District is now dotted with sleek, minimalist coffee shops and yoga studios that intermingle with low-income public housing. The enclave is intersected by Boulevard of the Arts, north of the lofty condo towers that dominate the downtown skyline. Built in 1971, the original McCown Towers’ aging facade is flanked by the more upscale, urban apartment buildings that have risen there in recent years.

City Manager Karie Friling was stark and serious about the parking garage during her presentation to the City Commission. She impressed upon the board that agreeing to the project was a significant financial decision it could not walk away from.

“You do not get to change your mind after today,” Friling said. “I want to make sure that’s very clear.”

She also acknowledged that there is a real need for public parking in the Rosemary District.

The city’s parking division is an “enterprise fund,” meaning its budget is supposed to be self-sustaining through rates and citations. But since 2013, the division has needed at least $3.9 million from the city’s general fund through subsidies and loans to stay solvent, according to previous reporting by Suncoast Searchlight.

A Tampa consulting firm hired by the city found that if the public portion of the garage was built, over 15 years parking in the Rosemary District should have a positive cash flow with rates of $1.50 an hour for on-street parking and $1 for off-street and garage spaces. 

Ahearn-Koch said she did not believe those projections were reliable, especially since they did not account for natural disasters such as hurricanes. It’s also not the first time city commissioners have heard similar projections that never materialized.

In 2019, the city completed a parking garage in St. Armands that was also supposed to pay for itself. The project increased parking capacity for visitors and has helped local businesses, but fell short of revenue projections, forcing the city to use $1.2 million in loans and transfers from its general fund to pay down the garage’s debt.

“The details and these assumptions and projections are really important because they’ve not, in my time on the commission, ever been accurate,” Ahearn-Koch said.

Friling said the city will now continue to explore options on how to bring more public parking to the Rosemary District, but did not mention any specific initiatives.

Christian Casale is a reporter for Suncoast Searchlight who covers local government and politics, and previously covered local government for the Sarasota Herald-Tribune. Email Christian at christian@suncoastsearchlight.org.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.